Shadowhawk

Shadowhawk’s Comic Reviews

Ratings Guide (Updated 26th July, 2013)

  • 9.5-10 – Worthy of being a classic and “Comic/Graphic Novel of the Year” status. Flaws can be ignored.
  • 8.5-9 - Minor noticeable flaws but a great book and “Comic/Graphic Novel of the Month” status.
  • 7-8 – Overall decent but some glaring flaws.
  • 5-6.5 – Too problematic. Recommended with caution.
  • 3-4.5 -Far too many flaws that outweigh any strengths. Not recommended.
  • 1-2.5 – Absolutely not recommended. Avoid at all costs.

A

B

C

D

F

G

  • Gage, Christos – Angel & Faith:Vol. 1Vol. 2,
  • Gage, Christos – G.I.Joe: Cobra: Vol. 1, Vol. 2 (with Mike Costa),
  • Gates, Sterling – Kirby: Genesis –  Captain Victory: Vol. 1,
  • Garing, Ken – Planetoid#1, #2,
  • Gillen, Kieron – Young Avengers: Vol. 1,
  • Gillen, Kieron – The Wicked + Divine: #1
  • Giffen, Keith – DC New 52: Justice League 3000: #1#3(with J.M. DeMatteis)
  • Gregory, Raven – Alice in Wonderland#1, #2, #3, #4, #5, #6,

H

  • Hawkins, Matt – Aphrodite IX: #1, #2, #3
  • Hartnell, Andy – Danger Girl: #1, #2, #3,
  • Heinberg, Allen – Wonder Woman Vol. 1,
  • Hickman, Jonathan – FF#1, #2,
  • Higgins, Kyle – DC New 52: Nightwing #25
  • Higgins, Kyle – C.O.W.L – #1 (with Alec Siegel)
  • Hill, Joe – Locke & Key – Vol. 1: Welcome to Lovecraft
  • Hine, David – The Darkness: Rebirth: Vol. 1
  • Hopeless, Dennis – Avengers Undercover: #1

J

K

L

M

N

P

  • Pak, Greg – DC New 52: Batman/Superman: #1, #2
  • Parks, Andre – Witchblade: Demon Reborn 
  • Palmiotti, Jimmy – Power Girl: Vol. 1, (with Justin Gray)
  • Palmiotti, Jimmy – DC New 52: Batman: The Dark Knight #23.2 – Mr. Freeze,

R

  • Rahner, Mark – Dejah Thorns and the White Apes of Mars#1, #2#3, #4,
  • Remeder, Rick – Captain America#1,
  • Remender, Rick – Black Science: #1, #2#3,
  • Remender, Rick – Deadly Class: #1
  • Remeder, Rick – Venom: Vol. 1,
  • Robinson, James – All New Invaders: #1
  • Robinson, James – DC New 52: Earth 2: #1, #2, #3, #4#5, #6, #7#8, #9, #10, #11, #12,
  • Rucka, Greg – Lazarus#1#2, #3
  • Rucka, Greg – Cyclops: #1
  • Rucka, Greg – Wolverine Vol. 1: The Brotherhood,

S

T

V

W

  • Wagner, Doug – Witchblade/Red Sonja#1, #2#3, #4, #5,
  • Waid, Mark – Daredevil: Vol. 1,
  • Waid, Mark – All New Marvel Now –  Daredevil: #1, #8
  • Waid, Mark - SupermanBirthright
  • Whedon, Zack – Serenity: Leaves on the Wind: #2
  • Williams, Rob – Revolutionary War: Knights of Pendragon #1
  • Willingham, Bill – Fables: Vol. 1 Vol. 2,
  • Willingham, Bill – Fairest: Vol. 1,
  • Wood, Brian – Star Wars#1#2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8, 
  • Wood, Brian – X-Men: #1